Credible minimum deterrence: A zero-sum game

cre

 PM Nawaz Sharif expressed determination at the National Command Authority Conference to not to engage in arms race.The participants of the conference were briefed on nuclear command and control structure and nuclear assets in a meeting presided by the PM. The participants expressed satisfaction at the security measures taken to secure the nuclear assets. It was decided in the meeting that an arms race should be discouraged but preparations will be made against conventional imbalances adding that no stone will be left unturned to preserve the national security of the country. Peace and stability in South East Asia is a vital part of Pakistan’s policy in the region, it was told during the conference. Acquisition of civil nuclear technology to counter energy crisis was also debated and it was agreed that such technology should be acquired. It was demanded during the meeting that Pakistan’s name should be added to nuclear suppliers list as Pakistan had met all the requirements for acquiring civil nuclear technology. Expressing satisfaction at the steps taken to abide by non-nuclear proliferation treaty, it was said that Pakistan is a mainstream partner of the treaty. The NCA meeting reiterated Pakistan’s interest in joining the multilateral export control regimes on a non-discriminatory basis, including membership of the Nuclear Suppliers Group to give it deserved full access to civil nuclear technology for peaceful purposes, particularly to meet its energy deficit. While the NCA reiterated its stance of peace and strategic stability in South Asia, for which conflict resolution was the necessary means, it also expressed concern at the absence of such a mechanism between Pakistan and India. A comprehensive briefing to the meeting by the Strategic Plans Division Director General dealt with the repeated apprehension in some quarters internationally that Pakistan’s nuclear weapons could fall into the wrong hands by pointing to the 30,000 strong security force guarding the nuclear arsenal. Reports have spoken lately about Pakistan possessing 120 nuclear warheads to India’s 100. But other reports also point to India’s rapidly growing nuclear and conventional military capabilities in the absence of a conflict resolution mechanism. The upsetting of regional strategic and conventional stability is a cause for concern. One think tank has reported that India has sufficient fissile material, both reactor and weapons grade plutonium, for more than 2,000 warheads. In addition, India is pursuing the addition to its arsenal of new weapons systems, including submarine-launched intercontinental and medium range ballistic missiles and improvements to its ballistic missiles defence. There is no reliable estimate available of India’s missile inventories. The growing conventional asymmetry is doubly dangerous in the presence of doctrines like Cold Start (a limited war). Juxtaposed with the current tensions with India, the dialogue suspended since January 2013 and skirmishes on the Line of Control and Working Boundary, the whole scenario is scary. The NCA’s argument that it does not want to enter into an arms race is correct in principle, but the ground realities and developments may inexorably lead to just such an outcome. It goes without saying that an arms race, nuclear or conventional or both, is not in the interests of either country, burdened by mass poverty and the demands of progress and development. The only way out of misperceptions about the other is to return to dialogue. The fact that the Pakistani Rangers-Indian Border Security Force meeting is taking place in New Delhi as these lines are being written is a hopeful chink of light in an otherwise dark horizon. The sooner Islamabad and New Delhi find the path back to the negotiating table, the better. That path seems to suggest itself in the light of the series of debacles in the dialogue as being none other than quiet diplomacy, proper preparation at the level of officials before the leaders meet, and the additional conduit of back channels that offer the advantage of discretion away from the glare of publicity.

 

pk.shafaqna.com

 

Share This Article