The recent convictions handed down by two separate Anti-Terrorism Courts (ATCs) have served as yet another stark reminder of how deeply entrenched and unresolved Pakistan’s current political crisis remains. On Tuesday, the courts delivered sweeping judgements, sentencing multiple political leaders and party workers to lengthy prison terms. The charges stemmed from allegations of delivering ‘provocative’ speeches, inciting riots, and participating in acts of vandalism linked to the events of May 9, 2023.
Rather than bringing a sense of closure, these verdicts have only deepened the political divide. Many critics argue that the cases lacked credible witness testimony and solid evidence connecting the accused directly to the incidents in question. As a result, they believe these convictions are likely to be overturned once they reach higher courts. This pattern is not unfamiliar in Pakistan’s political landscape. The country has a long and troubled history of prosecuting political figures on grave charges such as treason, sedition, and even murder—only for these same individuals to be acquitted years later, often returning to occupy positions of power. In fact, several members of the current ruling coalition have experienced similar trajectories.
History suggests that political disputes in Pakistan are seldom resolved through the legal system. Instead, they are often adjudicated in the court of public opinion, where people assess not only the actions of the accused but also the motivations of those pressing the charges. This is why the handling of the May 9 cases should have been far more measured. For instance, there was little justification for referring cases related to political speeches and protest-related violence to anti-terrorism courts. Such matters could and should have been addressed through standard criminal law procedures, which would have helped maintain public confidence in the legal process.
Unfortunately, the state chose to frame political dissent as terrorism, opting for a highly charged narrative that undermines democratic norms. To compound this, the trials were conducted in camera—behind closed doors—thereby denying the public an opportunity to witness justice being served. If the state indeed possessed “irrefutable evidence” and “undeniable testimonies,” as it claimed, there should have been no hesitation in presenting this information openly. By opting for secrecy, the authorities have only invited greater skepticism, further eroding trust in the judicial process and fueling suspicion over how these convictions were secured.
Adding to the concern is the prolonged detention of the accused. For nearly two years, those linked to the May 9 incidents have remained incarcerated, repeatedly denied bail as they awaited the outcomes of their trials. It’s worth noting that the recent verdicts may have been delayed even longer if the Supreme Court hadn’t intervened by setting deadlines for concluding these cases. Looking ahead, it is essential that any further proceedings be conducted transparently and openly, enabling independent observers and the general public to evaluate the fairness of the process.
Ultimately, Pakistan appears to be sliding back into a political vortex it has long tried to escape. The nation’s leaders must confront a timeless truth: political legitimacy cannot be manufactured through courtroom verdicts alone. Silencing dissent through judicial means may offer short-term victories, but in the long run, it is the public that delivers the final political judgement. The sooner those in power recognize this, the sooner the country can begin to move toward stability and democratic renewal.
Shafaqna Pakistan
pakistan.shafaqna.com
Note: Shafaqna do not endorse the views expressed in the article
