The deaths of two sanitation workers in Karachi earlier this month have once again exposed the dangerous and dehumanising conditions under which sanitation work continues to be performed in Pakistan. For decades, some of the country’s poorest and most marginalised workers have been expected to enter toxic sewers, often with little or no protective equipment. According to activists and occupational safety experts, 26 sanitation workers have died in similar incidents across Pakistan over the past eight months, including eight in Karachi and 18 in Punjab. These deaths should not be treated as routine workplace accidents. They reflect a serious failure to protect workers from known and preventable hazards.
Sending a human being into a sewer filled with poisonous gases, contaminated water and accumulated waste without appropriate safety equipment is both dangerous and unacceptable. No worker should have to risk his or her life simply because sanitation happens to be the only employment available. Proper protective gear, ventilation, gas detection equipment, emergency procedures and trained rescue teams should be basic requirements wherever sewer work is undertaken. More importantly, workers should not be sent into confined and toxic spaces when machines or remotely operated equipment can safely perform the task.
The problem also has a troubling social dimension. Activists have repeatedly drawn attention to the discriminatory nature of some sanitation jobs, where employment advertisements have historically specified that only members of certain religious minorities should apply. Such practices reinforce a deeply harmful social perception that hazardous, dirty and degrading work should be assigned to particular communities. Sanitation is an essential public service, and the people who perform it deserve the same dignity, protection and employment rights as workers in any other profession.
Another major concern is the widespread use of third-party contractors. Many sanitation workers are employed through private contractors rather than directly by government departments, creating uncertainty over responsibility and accountability. Successive governments have pledged to protect the dignity and rights of sanitation workers, yet meaningful safeguards remain inadequate. Contractual arrangements should never become a means of avoiding responsibility. Government departments and contractors must ensure that every worker, regardless of religion, social background or employment status, is provided with a safe workplace. Where negligence contributes to a worker’s death, those responsible should face appropriate accountability.
There is also little justification for continuing to send workers into sewers when mechanical alternatives are available. Reports that gutter-cleaning machines have been imported but remain unused while human beings continue to enter dangerous sewage systems point to a wider governance failure. Purchasing technology is not enough; it must be properly maintained, deployed and integrated into municipal operations. Pakistan should move towards a clear policy of zero human entry into sewage gutters wherever machines can safely perform the task.
This transition will require governments to conduct comprehensive audits of existing sanitation equipment, repair and deploy idle machines, and invest in modern robotic and remotely operated systems. Workers should also be trained to operate, maintain and supervise such equipment. Where conventional machines cannot safely handle particularly difficult environments, Pakistan can explore remotely operated systems and emerging robotic technologies. Engineers and sanitation workers can contribute valuable practical knowledge by documenting different sewer environments, obstacles, cleaning procedures and operating conditions. Such information could eventually help develop machines capable of performing hazardous tasks more safely and efficiently.
However, technological change must not come at the expense of workers’ livelihoods. Replacing a dangerous task with a machine should mean replacing the danger, not the worker’s income. Sanitation workers can be retrained for equipment operation, maintenance, waste management, municipal services and other related occupations. Governments should ensure that workers affected by mechanisation have access to training and alternative employment opportunities.
The objective should therefore be clear: people must be removed from dangerous sanitation work, not removed from their livelihoods. Pakistan’s cities depend on sanitation workers every day, yet these workers are too often treated as invisible. Protecting them requires more than statements of sympathy after another death. It requires enforcement of safety standards, an end to discriminatory employment practices, accountability for negligence and a determined shift towards mechanised and technology-based sanitation. No worker should have to choose between earning a living and risking their life.
Shafaqna Pakistan
pakistan.shafaqna.com
Note: Shafaqna do not endorse the views expressed in the article
