Gaza: Three Years of Devastation and an Unfinished Injustice/Shehryar Hassan

Today marks the third anniversary of a conflict whose devastating consequences have been witnessed by the world in real time. For three years, people across the globe have watched images of death, destruction and displacement emerge from Gaza, where Israeli military operations have reduced large parts of the territory to rubble. The scale of the suffering has made it impossible to treat the crisis as an ordinary episode of conflict. Whatever the circumstances that led to the war, the enormous civilian toll and the destruction of essential infrastructure have raised profound questions about proportionality, international law and the responsibility of states to protect civilian life.

There is no dispute that Israel came under attack on October 7, 2023, when Hamas-led fighters killed Israeli civilians and security personnel and took hostages. Israel has repeatedly described its subsequent military campaign as necessary for its security and for eliminating Hamas. Yet the scale and duration of the campaign have generated widespread international concern. The devastation in Gaza, the high number of civilian casualties and the repeated displacement of the population have prompted international organisations and rights groups to call for greater protection of civilians and compliance with international humanitarian law.

It is also important to place the events of October 7 within the much longer history of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The displacement of Palestinians, the occupation of Palestinian territories and the expansion of Israeli settlements long predate the current war. In the West Bank, Israeli settlement activity and violence have continued alongside the Gaza conflict, while Palestinians have faced restrictions on movement, property seizures and displacement. The events of the past three years have therefore unfolded against a longstanding political and territorial dispute that remains unresolved.

The humanitarian consequences in Gaza have been immense. Tens of thousands of Palestinians have been killed, according to international and local authorities, while many more have been injured. Large numbers of people remain displaced, often having been forced to move repeatedly in search of safety. Homes, hospitals, schools, roads and other civilian infrastructure have suffered extensive damage. Access to clean water, food, healthcare, shelter and education has remained severely constrained in many areas, leaving civilians dependent on humanitarian assistance.

At the same time, the conflict has had serious consequences beyond Gaza. Israeli military operations and clashes have affected the West Bank, Lebanon, Yemen and Iran, raising fears that the conflict could develop into a wider regional confrontation. Attacks and counterattacks have also threatened vital trade and energy routes, creating consequences far beyond the immediate battlefield. The growing regional instability demonstrates that the Gaza conflict cannot be separated from the broader political and security crisis in the Middle East.

The international response has also exposed deep divisions. The United States has remained Israel’s principal diplomatic and military supporter, while European and other Western governments have adopted varying positions, ranging from strong support for Israel’s security to calls for restraint, humanitarian access and a political settlement. At the same time, several governments and international institutions have pressed for investigations into alleged violations of international humanitarian law. The continuing disagreement over accountability has contributed to perceptions that international rules are being applied inconsistently.

Three years after the war began, the suffering of Palestinian civilians must not disappear from the international agenda simply because attention has shifted towards wider regional tensions. The people of Gaza cannot be treated as a secondary issue in discussions about Middle Eastern security. Any sustainable settlement will require serious attention to civilian protection, humanitarian access, the status of the occupied Palestinian territories and the political rights and security of both Palestinians and Israelis.

The anniversary should therefore serve as a reminder that military force alone cannot resolve a conflict rooted in decades of political, territorial and historical grievances. The international community must continue to press for accountability for alleged violations, protection of civilians and a credible political process capable of addressing the underlying causes of the conflict. Above all, the suffering of Palestinians and Israelis should not be reduced to another chapter in a cycle of violence. A lasting peace will remain impossible unless the rights, security and dignity of both peoples are recognised.

Shafaqna Pakistan

pakistan.shafaqna.com

Note: Shafaqna do not endorse the views expressed in the article

Share This Article